Close

"You cannot go wrong with compassion" - primatologist Frans de Waal - Sentientist Conversations

Find our Sentientist Conversation on the Sentientism YouTube and podcast.

Frans (fransdewaal.com) is a primatologist & ethologist. He is Professor of Primate Behavior at Emory University, director of the Living Links Center at Emory & the author of many books including "Chimpanzee Politics", "Our Inner Ape" & "The Bonobo & the Atheist". He has featured in TV/radio productions & TED talks viewed by tens of millions of people. His research centers on primate social behavior, including conflict resolution, cooperation, inequity aversion, & food-sharing. He is a member of the United States National Academy of Sciences & the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts & Sciences.

In Sentientist Conversations we talk about the two most important questions: “what’s real?” & “what matters?” Sentientism is "evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings." The audio is on our Podcast here on Apple and here on the other platforms. ​​​​ You can watch the video here.

We discuss:
0:00 Welcome

1:19 Frans' Intro - Understanding animals

  • Ethology, primates, animal behaviour, intelligence & morality
  • Breaking out of behaviourism. "We have so much evidence for animal intelligence… these taboos are being broken"
  • The ripple effect. Finding remarkable capabilities first in primates, then in many other species

4:05 What's Real? From Catholic to apathist

  • Growing up Catholic & dropping religion at 17
  • "My parents were very unhappy but I was part of a generation where everyone was doing that"
  • "The Bonobo & the Atheist" & human need for religion
  • Apathism… "I don't particularly care if god exists"
  • "In Catholicism & every religion there's a lot of hypocrisy… people who talk one way & act another"
  • Child abuse scandals & cover-ups
  • "Jesus was an inspiring figure… whether he's a real historical figure or not"
  • Half of people in the Netherlands call themselves atheists & we see that coming to the USA now

8:48 What Matters Morally?

  • Religion & evolution & intuition as drivers of morality
  • Religions can provide narratives to support your moral intuitions (e.g. the good samaritan)
  • "You cannot go wrong with compassion, morally"
  • Studying empathy in non-human animals
  • You can't build a moral system without empathy
  • Reasoning & logic, without compassion, can lead to awful harm
  • "Empathy & compassion are not human inventions"
  • Very young human children & dogs both show compassion to a crying person (Carolyn Zahn-Waxler)
  • We find compassion in many non-human animals & that is the basis for human morality too
  • The ability to detect sentience in others & to feel affected by it. Roots in maternal care (hence empathy more developed in females)? Oxytocin
  • "If you have a co-operative animal society you need to worry about you fellows"
  • "Empathy is a very adaptive trait"
  • The evolution of sentience as a class of info processing?
  • "I read 'Consciousness Explained' (Dennett) & I still don't know what it is"
  • We now know some animals can plan ahead
  • Sentience as experiencing things. "Certainly all animals with brains… must have experiences because they have bodies that need to react."
  • Plants? Mollusks?

20:50 Human Moral Development

  • Empathy can be parochial - restricted to those like us/in our tribe (Oxytocin drives out-group behaviour too). Compassion is more broad minded
  • "Be careful with oxytocin"
  • Moral development - we have to add to our evolved empathy
  • Non-humans & early humans didn't have a Geneva Convention
  • Extending moral consideration to non-human animals

24:49 Who Warrants Compassion?

  • Universal Declaration of Human Rights
  • "We don't want indiscriminate compassion - we also want commitments"
  • We can't abandon in-group prioritisation
  • Religious & non-religious ways of privileging humans
  • We value mammals/cuddliness/attractiveness more highly. "We are very biased"
  • We care about dogs in the west but not pigs. Yet there's not much of a difference
  • Struggling with the ethics of working with captive animals (always non-invasively & on a volunteer basis)
  • Being surrounded by people who conduct medical research on animals. Can it be justified? Moving to non-invasive, voluntary research
  • "People used to be dependent on animal meat… but that equation has changed… it's not strictly necessary any more"
  • "I'm not opposed to eating animals but I object to how the animals that we eat are being treated"
  • "As soon as you take people into a pig farm they will notice the problem"
  • Showing videos of farm/slaughterhouse conditions when people buy animal products?
  • "I eat barely any mammals any more"
  • We need to get rid of factory farming

42:52 The Future

  • Being less tribal & binary
  • "Nature is full of ambiguities"
  • "Humans are programmed to be in/out group animals"
  • Breaking the species boundary
  • "Our empathy is intended for our inner circle of family & friends but we have the capacity to expand it."
  • "We need to put pressure on the philosophers… The philosophers have given us… a philosophy where humans are set apart from the rest of nature"
  • "This whole idea that we dominate nature… because we are superior beings… that has given us the climate change problem, the pandemic…"
  • "Philosophers have always emphasised human uniqueness. As a biologist, I can tell you, humans are animals"
  • Human exceptionalism links back to ideas of the soul & mind/body dualism.

Sentientism is “Evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings.” More at sentientism.info​​​​​​​​​​​​​. Join our "I'm a Sentientist" wall using this simple form.

​Everyone interested, Sentientist or not, is welcome in our groups. The biggest so far is here on FaceBook​.

Thanks Graham for the post-production.

Latest work

Head-shot of Troy Vettese looking away to the left. Wearing white shirt.

Half-Earth Socialism - Troy Vettese - Sentientism Ep:191

Troy Vettese is an environmental historian and co-author, with Drew Pendergrass, of Half-Earth Socialism. A Sentientist conversation about "what's real?", "who matters?" and "how to make a better world?"
More

Half-Earth Socialism - Troy Vettese - Sentientism Ep:191

Troy Vettese is an environmental historian and co-author, with Drew Pendergrass, of Half-Earth Socialism. A Sentientist conversation about "what's real?", "who matters?" and "how to make a better world?"
More

"Your Neighbour Kills Puppies" - Tom Harris - Activist, Artist & Author - Sentientism Ep:190

Tom is an artist, published author, and social justice activist. He is an expert and consultant on animal liberation history and strategy, and the global animal rights movement. His first book, Your Neighbour Kills Puppies was released in March 2024. A Sentientism conversation.
More

Top 10 Conversations - according to the algorithms anyway...

Our Top 10 Sentientist Conversations... according to the algorithms.
More

Join our mailing list and stay up to date

Sentientism

Handcrafted with ♥ by Cage Undefined