"It just started to not make sense" ObjectivelyDan - Host of "Truth Wanted" Sentientism Episode 134

Find our Sentientist Conversation here on the Sentientism YouTube and here on the Sentientism podcast.

Objectively Dan is the host of Truth Wanted, a call-in talk show that's part of the Atheist Community of Austin.Truth Wanted focuses on how and why people believe what they believe - and how we can talk about beliefs in more effective ways - whether it’s karma or Christ, Bigfoot or crystals.

In Sentientist Conversations we talk about the two most important questions: “what’s real?” & “what matters?”

Sentientism is "evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings." The audio is on our Podcast here on Apple & here on all the other platforms.

We discuss:
00:00 Welcome

03:08 Dan's Intro

  • Listen to Truth Wanted! Is space real? Are there bug creatures on Mars?
  • "Americans in particular - not super great at the whole #epistemology stuff"

05:07 What's Real?

  • Growing up #Methodist , then switching to a #baptistchurch
  • Community more than theology "your parents went to church so you went to church"
  • "I did believe"
  • doing evangelical ministry
  • Being baptised twice!
  • Talking to @Anthony Magnabosco of @Street Epistemology "It was a stepping stone on a journey… I was already deconstructing"
  • "This faith thing doesn't really make sense"
  • Being an "igtheist" (basically an atheist) and a #Sentientist
  • @Being Reasonable 's Mark Solomon
  • The Bible "doesn't really stack up." Progressive Xtian & Xtian mystic phases
  • Reading @Sam Harris
  • "I was definitely homophobic… transphobic growing up". "My Christian faith told me it wasn't right, it wasn't natural"
  • "When you have a naturalist worldview it's harder to be homophobic"
  • Changing ethics & politics: abortion, immigration
  • "Christianity was all I knew… I didn't understand how to be a good person outside of Christianity"
  • Struggles of leaving Xtianity. Lacking community (no @Secular Student Alliance in Waco) "that was tough"
  • "There would be more athiests if it was more normal"
  • Atheists within religious communities
  • Selective dogmatism: #Qanon , #antivaxx , #goop products, #homeopathy
  • "#cognitivedissonance is a bitch"
  • "When you don't have someone who is actively challenging what you think you can just think what you want"
  • #miracles
  • "Churches aren't places for critical thinking"
  • #epistemology #fideism #dogma
  • Hebrews 11: "faith is the evidence of things not seen" enables any arbitrary belief
  • Most Xtian apologists & QAnon people claim to believe based on evidence & reason
  • "A #vegan sense of #ethics made sense"… talking to callers, reading books! "This was a blind spot for me"

34:09 What Matters?

  • Is-ought
  • Does #naturalism make it harder to have bad ethics?
  • Xtianity: "humans are fundamentally broken & sinful"
  • "Sometimes gods way is different… that is how you get people to do atrocious things"
  • Cognitive overload blocks people from changing "so many questions"
  • "Religion came after people… it's completely a human construct"
  • Morality as a human construct, but with pre-human roots?
  • God commanding Abraham to kill his son
  • "Hell definitely scared me." The trauma of leaving religion
  • Friends "who suddenly dropped me" for leaving Xtianity "they never talked to me again"
  • If your whole community disagrees with you "You might just fold"
  • Church fund-raising for gay #conversiontherapy : "I can't even go here any more"
  • The "hyper-rationalist" culture in some #atheist communities

47:07 Who Matters?

  • Vegans calling in to Truth Wanted & adopting a cat
  • Feeding live mice to a snake
  • "Why do human beings prioritise the lives of some animals over others"
  • Growing up around ranches & learning about #factoryfarming
  • "It just started to not make sense… I've gotta do it"
  • "I'm the only host at the ACA that is vegan… I'm frustrated… It's a serious blind-spot [in Atheist movements]… the conversations aren't even happening"
  • #AtheismPlus
  • Going vegan "felt like I was coming out as an atheist all over again"
  • Atheists & vegans being annoying is irrelevant to the arguments
  • "I was super nervous talking about veganism at first"
  • Atheists with bad reasons for being atheists & vegans with weaker reasons for being vegan (nutrition, purity, environment, spiritual)
  • Does confidence on one topic spill over into others?
  • Dangers of righteously motivated reasoning in veganism & atheism
  • Vegan emotional appeals often aren't sufficient for many in the atheist world
  • "Sentientism [& veganism) is 'out there' for most of the world" - it's going to get scrutiny
  • Considering edge cases in bad or good faith (being vegan on Twitter )
  • "Veganism is a complicated topic… we pretend that it's simple"
  • "People are afraid… because of the radical implications"
  • "I put #Sentientist in my twitter bio" #sentience
  • #PeterSinger & equal consideration of interests
  • "It's easier to convince people [that animals have interests] than this idea of sentience" to avoid the confusion around consciousness
  • #MelanieJoy & #Carnism
  • Can insentient entities like thermostats have "interests"? (no)
  • #Panpsychism, #freewill & #determinism

01:09:34 A Better Future?

  • How can we get atheist/#secular /#humanist /#skeptic /#rationalist communities to get serious about non-human sentient animal ethics?
  • #richarddawkins ' comments on Sentientism
  • @CosmicSkeptic & @Genetically Modified Skeptic going vegan & getting push-back "that was a big disappointment"
  • "I still hesitate talking about it [veganism]"
  • Having broad interests "helps normalise it…" vs. "veganism is your whole identity"
  • Sentientism drives compassionate, non-discriminatory intra-human ethics, not just our concern for non-human animals
  • Wild animal suffering "veganism doesn't say much about what goes on in the wild"
  • "Socrates… was totally cool with people being owned as slaves" & sexism
  • "It's easy to feel like we're losing… but there are battles that weren't happening before"
  • "Eastern philosophy has a more robust understanding of animal ethics… in the west 'this is the new hot thing that matters'"
  • American politics, #antisemitism & #kanyewest
  • "Have hope… don't give up the podcasts!"

Sentientism is “Evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings.” More at

Join our “I’m a Sentientist” wall using this simple form.

Everyone, Sentientist or not, is welcome in our groups. The biggest so far is here on Facebook.

Thanks to Graham for the post-production and to Denise for funding this episode via our Sentientism Patreon.

Latest work

Headshot of Luke McGuire. Smiling, wearing glasses, looking directly at the camera.

"Think more like six year olds!" - Psychologist Luke McGuire - Sentientism Ep:170

Luke is a lecturer working in the Department of Psychology at the University of Exeter. A podcast and YouTube conversation about Sentientism, what's real, who matters and how we can make a better world.

"Think more like six year olds!" - Psychologist Luke McGuire - Sentientism Ep:170

Luke is a lecturer working in the Department of Psychology at the University of Exeter. A podcast and YouTube conversation about Sentientism, what's real, who matters and how we can make a better world.

"Our beliefs are playing all sorts of roles... social, moral, epistemic…" - Psychologist Tania Lombrozo - Sentientism Ep:168

Tania is the Arthur W. Marks Professor of Psychology at Princeton University. A conversation about Sentientism, "what's real?", "who matters?" and "how to make a better world?"

What kind of relationships do we want with AI & other sentient beings? - Jared Moore - Novelist & AI Researcher - Sentientism Ep:167

Jared is an AI researcher and novelist. A conversation about what's real, who matters and how to make a better future. Sentientism is "evidence, reason and compassion for all sentient beings".

Join our mailing list and stay up to date


Handcrafted with ♥ by Cage Undefined