Aysha (@DrAyshaAkhtar & ayshaakhtar.com) is a neurologist, public health specialist & author. She is President & CEO of the Center for Contemporary Sciences. She worked for the Office of Counterterrorism & Emerging Threats of the FDA & served as Lieutenant Commander in the US Public Health Service. She is a Fellow of the Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics. Aysha wrote: “Animals & Public Health: Why treating animals better is critical to human welfare.“
In Sentientist Conversations we talk about the two most important questions: “what’s real?” & “what matters?” Sentientism is “evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings.” The audio is also on our Podcast – subscribe here on Apple & here on the other platforms.
0:00 Welcome & Sentientism
2:10 Aysha Intro
- Neurology, public health, emerging threats (e.g. pandemics)
- Setting up CCS to replace all animal research and testing with human relevant methods
4:27 What’s Real? Renouncing Islam, becoming atheist
- Growing up in a Pakistani Muslim family, but more culturally than strictly religious
- Calling herself a Muslim, but then seeing how her father & Muslim society treated girls & women differently
- Feeling pressure to dress modestly
- Announcing “I renounce Islam” at 11 yrs old
- Still believing in a god, then becoming an atheist
- “Why would a god care about me and not someone else living a miserable life?” “If there is a god, why is there so much suffering?”
- How can the suffering we cause animals be something a god could allow?
- Religion helps people feel less lost. Understanding why people cling to it
- Meaning, value, moral structure, purpose, community, love, awe & wonder are available naturalistically too.
15:50 What Matters Morally? All suffering & flourishing beings
- Keeping the good parts of religious morality
- “Living a life that causes the least amount of harm & the greatest amount of joy possible”
- “Of course that includes non-human animals because they feel, they have emotions”
- Our moral basics can be very simple
- Rights, dignity, personhood, sentience
- Why so much philosophy assumes only humans matter. The fundamental mistake of disregarding so much suffering
- People seem more concerned about the potential suffering of AI & mini organic brains, while not caring about animals
- Experiencing sexual abuse & finding solace with Sylvester the dog “my best friend”
- Finding out Sylvester was being physically abused & calling that out, then finding the confidence to stand up for herself
- Accidentally being sent PETA materials about the life of a dairy cow. The family went vegetarian that evening
- Being a vegetarian in the Pakistani community in the 1980’s was unheard of
- Being made fun of my other kids, but “I didn’t give a damn”. “I didn’t care what they thought about me I cared what they thought about the issue”
- Reading Regan, Singer. Finding the connections between human & non-human ethics & rights
- “We were such nerds”
31:05 What are sentience & consciousness?
- “I don’t know”, you can dig deeper & deeper
- “It’s a human made construct”
- The core question is “can a being suffer” & we can assess that
- “We like to think we’re above the physical”, but “Our consciousness is deeply tied in with our anatomy” (dementia, injury, illness, drugs…)
- Powerpointism & panpsychism
- Meditation & introspection
38:03 The Future – Star Trek? Ending animal research & testing
- Star Trek: broad compassion & naturalism
- “Not only can we get there, we have to get there”
- “This pandemic started because of animal exploitation” but “unfortunately people aren’t going to learn”
- Climate change
- Empathy is innate in our species & it will grow as we grow
- Humanity as a species is an adolescent
- Has the moral argument re: non-human animals already been won?
- A #JustTransition to help those who depend on animal exploitation
- Why so many vegans exclude wild animal suffering
- Animal testing as an unpopular topic
- Maybe animal testing played a role but we’re beyond that now
- “What is the best way to understand human biology today?” It’s to get back to studying human biology
- We have so little to show for animal testing
- We call for diversity in human clinical trials but we’re still testing on animals!
- 90-95% of US drugs/vaccines fail. They’ve all passed animal tests!
- Most animal testing isn’t even developing treatments. Why are we doing drug addiction & tobacco research on monkeys?
- Ethics boards are “foxes guarding the henhouse”
- CCS: Better alternatives (and moral pressure)
Everyone, Sentientist or not, is welcome in our groups. The biggest so far is here on Facebook.