Close

“Children are much less speciesist than adults” – Psychological Researcher Matti Wilks – New Sentientist Conversation

Matti (@matti_wilks​ & mattiwilks.com​) is a post-doctoral researcher at Yale University, working with Professor Paul Bloom. She studies moral psychology & moral development – including attitudes to cultivated meat & the “natural”, the moral status of various types of entities & altruism.

In these Sentientist Conversations we talk about the two most important questions: “what’s real?” & “what matters?” Sentientism is “evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings.” Click on the video above or here to watch. The audio is also on our Podcast – subscribe on Apple here & the other platforms here.

We discuss:

  • Doing research to make the world a better place (& curiosity)
  • Growing up non-religious (w/ ex-Jewish father) & vegetarian
  • Seeing the benefits & value in religion: Community & compassion
  • Open-mindedness & humility
  • The danger of over-confidence in naturalism & science
  • Researching ve*an children in meat-eating households
  • Parallels between religious & omnivore societal defaults and indoctrination/norm setting
  • Many “religious” people don’t actually hold to the supernatural beliefs
  • Why do we have morality & what should morality be about?
  • Being uncertain about whether there are moral truths
  • Harm & suffering as inherently bad. The drive to reduce suffering
  • Haidt et al’s Moral Foundations Theory
  • Even if nothing matters to the universe, experiences matter to each individual sentient being
  • Would Isaac killing his son have been right? (No)
  • Isn’t choosing whether to care about suffering just choosing whether to be moral?
  • People seem to be more ethically motivated than they used to be
  • Even Greenwashing is a sign that more people care about the environment
  • Public negativity re: factory farming
  • Having the capacity to act more ethically is a privilege (being free of survival needs)
  • Moral relativism
  • Growing up around animals & becoming an “outraged” activist at 15-16 yrs
  • Studying animal cognition. “The Gap” by Thomas Suddendorf
  • Humans do have distinctive capacities but all sentient animals qualify for moral consideration
  • The importance of the moral scope boundary
  • Sentientism as pluralistic re: ethical systems
  • Degrees of sentience vs. egalitarian approaches
  • Sentience as a class of information processing?
  • Most people don’t want to cause animal suffering, but personal/cognitive costs impede & their level of concern is lower than it should be vs. human exceptionalism
  • Cognitive dissonance & motivated reasoning
  • Most religious people still use naturalism for most decisions
  • Supernatural and (flawed) scientific ways of justifying radical human supremacy
  • Simpler sentients (non-human animals, human babies?) might even suffer more than humans. We can often mitigate our suffering
  • “Humans are special, but not quite as special as we think we are”
  • “We need to stop asking people to do the hard moral work”. Activists really want people to make a moral change
  • “Once people change their behaviour they might be able to change their attitudes and start caring more”
  • Cultured/cultivated meat as an example. People can keep doing what they enjoy but without the harms
  • Righteousness & preaching are understandable but rarely effective
  • The challenges of hiding our righteous indignation in order to engage constructively with others
  • To change minds: Start from source they trust or with something they already agree with
  • “If you care enough to be an advocate, you’re already not representative of your audience”. What motivates you probably won’t motivate them (e.g. many people go veg*n for health reasons)
  • Tracy Schultz’ work re: disturbing images
  • Is it naive to think kids are compassionate naturalists?
  • “Young children weigh human & animal lives much more closely than adults do”
  • “Young children are much less speciesist than adults” 1 human : 1.5 dogs or 6 pigs vs. 1 human : 100 animals
  • In-group bias peaks at 4-5 yrs
  • “Our strong speciesism is something we learn socially”
  • The gap between belief & behaviour “X is wrong but I’m curious/tempted”
  • We’ve won the moral argument. So focus more on making it easy (& normal) for people to change behaviour (but keep eyes on the moral outcome!)
  • Going veg*n with others makes it much easier & more sticky
  • It’s great you’re on a journey but don’t stop
  • “Natural” rejection of GMOs/Golden Rice & similar risks for cultivated meat. Process over content
  • Emotion (strong) vs. evidence (weak) re: updating beliefs.

Sentientism is “Evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings.” More at sentientism.info​​​​​​​​​​​​​.

Join our “I’m a Sentientist wall” using this simple form.

Everyone interested, Sentientist or not, is welcome to join our groups. Our main one is here on FaceBook.

Thanks, Graham for the post-production. Follow him at @cgbessellieu​.

Latest work

Headshot of Jimmy Videle smiling towards the camera. Wearing a grey hoodie with the hood up - and glasses.

Is Veganic the Future of Farming? “We grow plants using plants” – Jimmy Videle – Sentientism Ep:192

Jimmy Videle is a farmer, naturalist and researcher. He is the author of The Veganic Grower’s Handbook. A Sentientism conversation about "what's real?", "who matters?" and "how to make a better world?"
More

Is Veganic the Future of Farming? “We grow plants using plants” – Jimmy Videle – Sentientism Ep:192

Jimmy Videle is a farmer, naturalist and researcher. He is the author of The Veganic Grower’s Handbook. A Sentientism conversation about "what's real?", "who matters?" and "how to make a better world?"
More

Half-Earth Socialism – Troy Vettese – Sentientism Ep:191

Troy Vettese is an environmental historian and co-author, with Drew Pendergrass, of Half-Earth Socialism. A Sentientist conversation about "what's real?", "who matters?" and "how to make a better world?"
More

“Your Neighbour Kills Puppies” – Tom Harris – Activist, Artist & Author – Sentientism Ep:190

Tom is an artist, published author, and social justice activist. He is an expert and consultant on animal liberation history and strategy, and the global animal rights movement. His first book, Your Neighbour Kills Puppies was released in March 2024. A Sentientism conversation.
More

Join our mailing list and stay up to date

Sentientism

Handcrafted with ♥ by Cage Undefined