Close

“Change is possible but hard” – Jeff Sebo – Author, Activist, Academic – New Sentientist Conversation

Jeff Sebo is Clinical Assoc. Prof. of Environmental Studies, Affiliated Professor of Bioethics, Medical Ethics, & Philosophy, & Director of the Animal Studies M.A. Program at New York University. He is on the executive committee at the NYU Center for Environmental & Animal Protection & the advisory board for the Animals in Context series at NYU Press. He is a board member at Animal Charity Evaluators, a board member at Minding Animals International, an Exec. Cttee. member at the Animals & Society Institute, and a Senior Fellow at Sentient.

In these Sentientist Conversations we talk about the two most important questions: “what’s real?” & “what matters?”

Sentientism is “evidence, commitment & compassion for all sentient beings.”

The audio is also on our Podcast – subscribe on Apple here & most other platforms via Anchor.

We discuss:

  • Jeff’s background in moral & political philosophy & his shift to focus on animal & environmental ethics
  • Multi-disciplinary approaches
  • Using academia to drive real change
  • Growing up in a Christian household & connecting with religious community (e.g. leading youth groups)
  • Considering going into ministry
  • College at Texas Christian University (liberal arts focus, but many conservative Christian students)
  • Facing a wave of challenges to religious beliefs & having a major faith crisis
  • “I never really believed the Christian stuff in the first place as much as I thought I did… in fact, I was just invested in the community.”
  • A reactionary atheism phase: “God is dead, life is absurd!”
  • Re-constructing a more generous interpretation of religious & scientific beliefs
  • Deep humility re: the fundamental nature of reality
  • The limits to empirical testing. There might be truths beyond those limits
  • “Use evidence & reason to study what we can but recognise that they will not be able to grasp everything of interest in the world”
  • Avoiding certainty (whether supernatural or claimed naturalistic), but also avoiding nihilism & giving up
  • Socrates’ Euthyphro dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euthyphro
    ​ (are gods expressing the “good” or are gods good by identity?)
  • Formal constructivism & anti-realism (values are things we create for ourselves)
  • JW: “Before sentient beings existed, there was no morality”
  • Christine Koorsgard: Value as an intrinsic aspect of agency
  • Sharon Street (formal constructivism): Contingent reasons drive overlap in our values (bio/cog/culture)
  • We can still constrain an ideally coherent Caligula who enjoys torturing
  • “You don’t have to be moral, but the rest of us will constrain you”
  • Valenced experience of sentient beings (suffering/flourishing) as a moral grounding
  • Other perspectives for moral value beyond sentience?
  • “My credence that Sentientism is the correct & only theory of moral status is lower than 1 but it is relatively high”
  • Sentientism can rule out moral systems that are agreed within groups if they needlessly cause suffering
  • Justifying practical ethics using meta-physics is skipping too many layers, but “suffering is bad” is pretty practical
  • Growing up “normal” re: non-human animals
  • Falling in love with ethics & existentialism
  • Singer, Regan, Rachels
  • “Sentience is, if not necessary, then at the very least sufficient for moral consideration”
  • Going vegetarian then vegan
  • Building an identity as an animal advocate
  • Being open-minded about the scope of sentience
  • The difficulty of assessing sentience & openness to broad sentience (plants, AI, all matter?)
  • Danger of humans focusing on Sentience as a “things like us” characteristic (we’ve been too restrictive historically with other characteristics)
  • Sentience as a counter to anthropocentrism
  • Sentience as an evolved capacity… but why does it have to come with phenomenological consciousness. Why should it “feel like” anything? The “hard problem”
  • Or is Sentience just what it feels like to run this type of info proc?
  • Mental states about mental states. A conception of the self
  • Sentience vs. consciousness
  • The future: Including animals in public policy – a multi-species political society. Extend human politics (democracy, liberalism) or re-think from scratch
  • “The future needs to look really different!”
  • A unified multi-species approach, acknowledging differing norms
  • Practical common ground (e.g. end animal farming) between diverse approaches
  • “Just transition”
  • Re-writing SDGs & the UDHR for all sentients
  • Aspire then act.

Follow Jeff at @jeffrsebo​ & find him at jeffsebo.net

Sentientism is “Evidence, reason & compassion for all sentient beings.” More at https://sentientism.info/​​​​. Join our “wall” ​using this simple form.

Everyone interested, Sentientist or not, is welcome in our groups. Our biggest (~90 countries so far) is here on FaceBook. ​

Thanks to Graham for his post-prod work. Follow him: @cgbessellieu.

Latest work

In the classroom!

I recently gave this presentation (YouTube and podcast links below) to a network of Religious Education (RE) teachers from Northumberland in the UK. It’s aimed at helping teachers bring the […]
More

In the classroom!

I recently gave this presentation (YouTube and podcast links below) to a network of Religious Education (RE) teachers from Northumberland in the UK. It’s aimed at helping teachers bring the […]
More

Just How Big Should “The Moral Circle” Be? – Jeff Sebo on Sentientism Ep: 229

Jeff Sebo is Associate Professor of Environmental Studies at New York University. A Sentientism conversation about his new book "The Moral Circle".
More

Our First IRL Sentientism Meetup! Plus Education and Other Updates

If you’re in range of London on the 27th July come and join our first in person meetup, a picnic in Regent’s Park. As with all of our communities and […]
More

Join our mailing list and stay up to date

Sentientism

Handcrafted with ♥ by Cage Undefined